Tony McCollister received 15 years to life in Warren County, while reports conflict on Erica Grove’s prison term.

WCPO reports Judge Robert Peeler gave Grove 84 months, or seven years.

The Dayton Daily News identifies the sentencing date as Tuesday, Nov. 10, but reports an eight-year total for Grove. The accounts conflict on that total.

The available reporting does not resolve the discrepancy. A court sentencing entry is needed to reconcile those accounts.

Different trial outcomes

WCPO’s Oct. 1 trial report says Peeler convicted McCollister of rape, gross sexual imposition and child endangering. It also records that Grove was acquitted of rape but convicted on other charges.

The sentencing reports concern crimes against a child. The child is not identified here.

Investigation began with a digital tip

The Warren County Prosecutor’s Office said in February that Google sent a tip about possible child sexual abuse material in June 2025.

The tip went to the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children, then to Ohio’s Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force. The task force forwarded it to the Warren County Sheriff’s Office, according to the prosecutor.

The prosecutor said detectives obtained search warrants and connected material to an account belonging to McCollister. The office identified both defendants as Union Township residents.

That February statement announced indictments. It predates the trials and does not establish either defendant’s sentence.